Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCorrespondencep g g yg gy V COUNTY of FREDERICK Department of Planning and Development 540/ 665-5651 Fax: 540/ 665-6395 107 North Kent Street, Suite 202 • Winchester, Virginia 22601-5000 February 3, 2026 Dan Brzezynski (via email: dbrzezynski@pennoni.com) Pennoni 117 East Piccadilly Street, Suite 200 Winchester, Virginia 22601 Re: Review Comments for Site Plan #52-25 – Carmeuse Eastern Berm Property Identification Number (PIN): 34-A-11 Dear Dan: Planning Staff has reviewed the above-referenced site plan to determine if administrative approval can be granted. At this time, administrative approval cannot be granted. This site plan cannot be approved until the issues in this letter, as well as all issues of the other review agencies, have been adequately addressed. Please review Staff’s comments listed below and then prepare a revised site plan which adequately addresses each concern. Review Comments: (1) Cover Sheet/General Notes. a) Reference Number. Add the site plan reference number #52-25. b) Excavation Notes. Excavation shall be no closer than 100 feet from any property zoned RA, RP, R4, R5 or MH1. No excavation shall be located closer than 200 feet from any dwelling or platted residential subdivision. (§165-608.05(B)(2)). Excavation shall be no closer than 100 feet from any road, street, or highway right-of-way. The Board of Supervisors may reduce the required front setback for excavation to 50 feet if it determines that, through the use of measures, such as landscaping or screening, the effective protection afforded to adjacent properties has not been reduced. (§165-608.05(A)(2)). Provide these notes on the coversheet and distances, measured in feet, to the site plan. c) Machinery Notes. All crushing or screening machinery shall be set back at least 300 feet from any property boundary. (165-608.05(B)(3). Provide these notes on the coversheet and the distances, measured in feet, to the site plan. (2) Additional Requirements. All uses in the EM District must conform with all state, federal, and local regulations. All mining operations shall submit to the Zoning Administrator a copy of the operations plan required by state agencies with the required site plan. Provide the necessary documentation from the Department of Mining & Minerals. (3) Photometric Plan. A photometric plan is required to be provided that includes lighting levels (foot candles) at the property line. Additionally, a note shall be added stating all outdoor lighting shall conform to §165-201.07 and be designed, shielded, aimed, located and maintained to shield adjacent properties and shall be full-cutoff fixtures. (§165-201.07(B)(1). If no lighting is proposed provide a note that states so. (4) Agency Approvals. Comment sheets (approvals) are required from the following agencies: the Frederick County Inspections Department, the Frederick County Fire Marshal, Virginia Department of Transportation, Frederick Water, and the Frederick County Engineer (Public Works). Additional comments may be provided on subsequent submission. After you have revised the site plan, please resubmit one (1) hard copy so that Staff may verify the information contained on the plan addresses the above comments. Staff will also need all approved review agency comment sheets, recordation of the plat (as applicable), at least five (5) copies of the final plan set and a digital (PDF) copy for approval. Do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions or concerns regarding this letter. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Amy Feltner Planner ALF/pd cc: O-N Minerals (Chemstone) Company, c/o Carmeuse Lime & Stone, Inc., 6920 Pointe Inverness Way, Suite 301, Fort Wayne, IN 46804 117 East Piccadilly Street, Suite 200 T: 540-667-2139 www.pennoni.com Winchester, VA 22701 Page 1 of 2 February 26, 2026 Ms. Amy Feltner Planner County of Frederick Department of Planning and Development 107 North Kent Street, Suite 202 Winchester, VA 22601 RE: SP #52-25 – Carmeuse Eastern Berm Ms. Feltner, We are in receipt of your comments dated February 3, 2026, for the review of SP #52-25 – Carmeuse Eastern Berm. We have addressed your comments and our specific responses are noted below. 1. Reference Number. Add the site plan reference number #52-25 RESPONSE: Site Plan number has been provided. See sheet CS0000. 2. Excavation Notes. Excavation shall be no closer than 100 feet from any property zoned RA, RP, R4, R5 or MH1. No excavation shall be located closer than 200 feet from any dwelling or platted residential subdivision. (§165-608.05(B)(2)). Excavation shall be no closer than 100 feet from any road, street, or highway right-of-way. The Board of Supervisors may reduce the required front setback for excavation to 50 feet if it determines that, through the use of measures, such as landscaping or screening, the effective protection afforded to adjacent properties has not been reduced. (§165- 608.05(A)(2)). Provide these notes on the coversheet and distances, measured in feet, to the site plan. RESPONSE: Notes have been provided and setbacks have been identified on the plan. See sheets CS0000 & CS1000 thru CS2201. 3. Machinery Notes. All crushing or screening machinery shall be set back at least 300 feet from any property boundary. (165-608.05(B)(3). Provide these notes on the coversheet and the distances, measured in feet, to the site plan. RESPONSE: Notes have been provided and setbacks have been identified on the plan. See sheets CS0000 & CS1000 thru CS2201. 4. Additional Requirements. All uses in the EM District must conform with all state, federal, and local regulations. All mining operations shall submit to the Zoning Administrator a copy of the operations plan required by state agencies with the required site plan. Provide the necessary documentation from the Department of Mining & Minerals. February 26, 2026 SP #52-25 – Carmeuse Eastern Berm FCP&D – Ms. Amy Feltner Page 2 of 2 RESPONSE: The current Operations plan has been provided with the resubmission. 5. Photometric Plan. A photometric plan is required to be provided that includes lighting levels (foot candles) at the property line. Additionally, a note shall be added stating all outdoor lighting shall conform to §165-201.07 and be designed, shielded, aimed, located and maintained to shield adjacent properties and shall be full-cutoff fixtures. (§165-201.07(B)(1). If no lighting is proposed provide a note that states so. RESPONSE: A note has been provided as no lighting is proposed or required. See sheet CS0000. 6. Agency Approvals. Comment sheets (approvals) are required from the following agencies: the Frederick County Inspections Department, the Frederick County Fire Marshal, Virginia Department of Transportation, Frederick Water, and the Frederick County Engineer (Public Works). RESPONSE: Noted and provided with submission. If you have any comments or questions, please feel free to contact us. Thank you. Dan Brzezynski, PE Project Manager Pennoni 117 East Piccadilly Street | Winchester, VA 22601 Direct: +1 540-771-2090 www.pennoni.com | DBrzezynski@Pennoni.com LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL DATE: 12.05.2025 JOB NO. CRMUL25002 TO: Frederick County Dept. of Planning & Development 107 North Kent Street, 2nd Floor Winchester, VA 22601 ATTENTION: Plans Review – Amy Feltner FROM: Dan Brzezynski RE: Carmeuse Eastern Berm Project Site Plan WE ARE SENDING YOU ☒ Attached Via: the following items: ☐ Plans ☐ COPIES DESCRIPTION 1 Site Plan – Carmeuse Eastern Berm Project THESE ARE TRANSMITTED as checked below: ☒ For Review and Comments ☐ For Your Approval ☐ For Your Use ☐ As Requested REMARKS COPY TO File RECEIVED BY 117 East Piccadilly Street Winchester, VA 22601 Tel: 540 – 667 - 2139 Fax: 540 – 665 - 0493 Account #: 8027519 As of: 12/2/2025 9:21:32 PM PID: 27519 Frederick County Report Property Owner Name:O-N MINERALS (CHEMSTONE) COMPANY D/B/A CARMEUSE LIME & STONE INC Mailing Address: 6920 POINTE INVERNESS WAY STE 301 FORT WAYNE , IN 46804 7926 Parcel Use:COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIA - VAC Magisterial District:05 - STONEWALL Property Information Physical Address:0  BRUCETOWN RD  Tax Map #:34/ A/ 11/ / Size (Acres):98.72 Legal Description:98.72 ACRES Utilities Year Gas Electric Sewer Water Utilities Street Type Lot Type 2025 No Electric None None N/A Gravel N/A Current Assessment Year Land Improvements Land Use Value Total 2025 $681,200 $0 N/A $681,200 Land Land Type Size Units Unit Price Appraised Commercial 98.72 ACRES 6,900.00 681,200.00 Total 98.72 681,200 Deed Transfers Deed Date Book Page Deed Type Est. Sale Owner 11/3/2022 13329 0 LR $5,922,000 O-N MINERALS (CHEMSTONE) COMPANY 11/1/1995 848 606 LR $0 FREDERICK LAND COMPANY LC 1/1/1900 0 0 LR $0 FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF YORK Not a Legal Document Subject to terms and conditions www.actDataScout.com Map  1 Carmeuse Americus – Winchester Plant 2021 Current legal company name O-N Minerals (Chemstone) Company Operations Narrative: The mining operation, in Clearbrook, Virginia, started in 1960. The Global Stone Corporation purchased the operation in 1999. The mining method is an open pit quarry operation. Stone is mined from three different seams: Lenoir – low calcium Mosheim – high calcium Beekmantown – low calcium A contract driller and blaster is utilized in the pit. Carmeuse provides equipment for the rest of the operation – loading, hauling, crushing, and sizing. There is one primary crushing plant. There is a high calcium sand plant for manufacturing glass sand and feeding calcium. High calcium limestone is also process through our vertical lime kilns to manufacture a pebble lime product. Furthermore, there is an aggregate plant that manufactures various sized limestone aggregate. W&L of Virginia has an asphalt plant located on the property. Frederick County of Virginia has a water treatment plant on the property. Italia Cemente operates a concrete batch plant. All three sites have been carved off the mining permit. Drainage Control Current drainage patterns are shown on the amendment maps, as blue arrows. Drainage is controlled by diverting the water either into the quarry excavation or by collecting the stormwater runoff in storm water sumps. Water is temporarily retained which allows sediment to settle out in the catchment areas prior to pumping and discharge according to the parameters of our existing VPDES discharge monitoring requirements. The current Pit elevation is 402’ approximately 200’ deep, with the final planned elevation at approximately 360’ above sea level. Water from the Pit area is pumped out for plant process water as needed, if not needed; water is pumped into Clear Brook Run. Mining waste material, overburden and topsoil stockpile areas are shown on the mine map. Screening berms will be used and will be setback a minimum of no closer than 25 feet from the property boundary. Typical berm cross sections are enclosed based on type of material and slope required in DMME regulations. Fill slopes will be graded to a maximum of 2:1 slopes for predominantly clay soils. Fill slopes may be graded steeper if a 1.5 static safety factor can be shown. 2 There is a DMM approved on-site disposal area. It is currently being used for off spec lime. The acceptable on-site generated wastes (tires, screen cloth etc.) are being sent off-site for recycling or disposal. As mining progresses, some open pit areas will be backfilled with overburden and on-site generated mine wastes. Other pits will have to remain open to allow access to future underground reserves. Concurrent with mining, inactive slopes of elevated overburden fills will be contoured to acceptable grades and temporarily re-vegetated if undisturbed for a 12-month period. Also concurrent with mining, other inactive disturbed areas undisturbed for an approximant 24 month period will be covered with stone or re- vegetated according to the after mining plan to prevent erosion. The overburden pile will be contoured in 50 foot lifts sloped two to one. The bench at the base of each slope will be approximately 20 feet wide with a berm to the outside and a swale on the inside for drainage control. This swale will direct drainage towards open pits for settlement control and will employ periodic stone check dams to slow water velocity. Post Mining Land Use The final quarry excavations will be allowed to fill with water to supply the Frederick County water treatment plant or other interested parties. Mining equipment will be removed prior to occupation by Frederick Water. Facilities will be constructed for the management of water storage such as access roads, small buildings and enclosures, pumping equipment and water monitoring. Other reclamation will be accomplished by the appropriate contouring and seeding. Fill slopes will be graded to a maximum of 2:1 slopes for predominately clay soils or steeper slopes may be used that exhibit a safety factor of 1.5. Rocky slopes may be graded steeper if a 1.5 static safety factor can be shown. Areas which will not support vegetation, such as solid rock areas, will not be re-vegetated. Re-vegetated areas will be fertilized using a 10-10-10 blend at 300 lbs. per acre and seeded following the currently approved DMME seed mixture requirements. Builds, equipment, and debris will be removed as necessary to allow future industrial uses of the land. Hydrogeology Evaluation Summary This application references a hydrogeology evaluation submitted with previous applications by Science Application International Corporation for Frederick Co. that analyzed the effect of a water withdrawal well from the same geologic formation and in the same groundwater catchment basin as the Global Stone Chemstone Winchester Quarry. The report concluded that the well has a reliable yield of 0.5 million gallons per day (mgd) in the catchment area that has over 2.2 mgd of groundwater available and should not have an unreasonable impact on the aquifer. The quarry normally pumps 0.864 mgd of which over 10% of the water is reused in the wash plant, screening plant, 3 dust control and water truck applications. Also, a large percentage of the water we pump is surface water, not groundwater, which falls directly into the quarry drainage area. Assuming a 90 acre drainage area and an annual precipitation of 27.99 in. (climate.virginia.edu) = 0.25 mgd of surface water. Therefore, the estimated overall groundwater withdrawal attributed to the quarry operation, 50% of 0.86 mgd minus the 0.25 mgd of surface water equals 0.31 mgd. This is significantly less than the 0.50 mgd withdrawal rate that was determined to be acceptable from the SAIC groundwater study. In 2018 Electro Resistivity testing was performed on the property to be added to mining. This was done to evaluate the potential impact on subsurface water and potential source for a spring adjacent to mining activity. This spring supplies water to one structure owned by Carmeuse and possibly to an adjacent property. The report suggests the source of the spring is both shallow and deeper ground water sources. With this knowledge, we are prepared to maintain the spring discharge should our mining impact it. Should our mining cause the spring water to enter the pit area we will pump this water to a permitted outfall in the same water course.