HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-16 Comments102 Raven Rd, Stephens City VA 22655
Looking East
Looking South
Frederick County, W
01
Current
o
Zonin� Map
0Z 03 04
04
05 06 09
15
12
0 0.5 1 2 3 4 �7 { i - ---_. �:•,_. �\ I_ _... ___ _ "___ _.. _--
i
�_ r'•.
w1. - 16 19 20 ..21+ 22 i,.\1.3 24
Map Created by Frederick County i 1�
Dept o(PlanninghDevelopmem -. �, ._ ..,- - 6
107 N Kant Street o ( r• 'c pf
Suite 202 I __�.�.�.�_�
Wineha ter< VA 22601
540.6655651
FEDGRCK.VA.US 2$ , d 29 p, 30 32www CO. 72
34
May 2016 A ,..
AMENDED:--
DECEMBER 14, 2011 (REZ # Ol -11)
MARCH 14, 1011 (REZ# 01 - 12) F _-. -___ <\ M`'u .x. / ti )� �•w
MARCH 14, 2012 (REZ # 02 - 12) +jci'EAy.-
k.
/S
MAY 8, 20-1 13 (AG/fOREST OLSTRl'CT$) l /.; - ,r' "� q Y > 4 /
JUNE 12, 2013 (REZ # 02 -13) %, l �a! I (\
OCTOBER 09 2013 (REZ # 04 - 13)�� - `
DECEMB_2
R 11, 2013 (REZ # o3 - 13) 36 37 d 38 39 49 1 42- �` 1r •�•�� 45 ' t
MAY28, 2014 (AG/FORESTAL DISTRICTS) �+
AUGUST 33, 2014 (REZ #OI-14) J
AWUST BI
T
r Q Ay�
NOVEMBER 1I, 201413,2014 �SWSA EXPANSION)
�._� ,.✓' T.. - 6� - - ._....app 'e(
OCTOBER 8, 2014 (REI # 03 -14 _ _ _ _ •°
NOVEMBER 12, 2014 (REZ # O4 - 14 T ({� "'s
FEBRUARY 25 2015(SWSA EXPANSION) i"
MAV 13, 2015 (REZ # 01 -15) L �' - _ �• /:._1 i. �\
MAY 2Z, 2015 (AG/FORESTAL DISTRICM1 G ,; •�._ P f � r
JUNE 10, 3025 (REZ # 03 - IS) 47 48 59 51 l 5vh + 53 54� 5,� 56
JULY S, 2015 (REZ # 02 - 15) 8 ' , 7
AUGUST 12, 2015 (AG/FORESTAL DISTRICTS) l` f•� Y<21 T' f '_6•
OCTOBER ZB 2015 (REZ#OS-IS) / ' _ `if-.• � �
NOVEMBER 12, ZDIS (AG/FORESTALDISTRICTS),
NOVEMBER 12, 2015 (REZ # 08 - 15)
DECEMBER 9, 2015 (REZ #06 -
DECEMBER 9, 2015(REZ#OZ-t5) %l:• /` \ y f - !. N,� / ":Yi
DECEMBER 9 2015 (REZ # 09 - 15)
t a4'v
DECEMBER 9 3015 (REI # 10 - IS) j 1
' 59so
JANUARYIX 2016 (REZ# I] - t5) 57.66 V TF"'y4' 62 63. - 66
IANUAAY 27, 2016 (REZ # ]2 -15)
APRIL 13, 2016 (REZ # Ol 16) I f �,l' { p2 �1
A5j
APRIL 2] 2016 (REZ # 01-16) i
NAY 25, 2016(REZ #03-16)f^'-a•8< 1
67 68 69.- J 70 71 i2 -74 75 76 37
yfi0r r �0
i!�'r ift
/
8 �, 79 80 81 82 85 86` s7�
_i --__ - -`a_. -U• 4 t { --_ _. f�
88 89 �J0 t f 91 `. 92 '93,. f' 94
Dave and Kate Dentel
102 Raven Road
Stephens City,Va.22655
Jtuic 2016
bequest for or inu Vanaince'.
Te boom 2E o'tS
N hTINI,ALF AVL I
To the South:
As a double lot, 100 Raven
Road also has ample potential
for building expansion, despite
being bound by two "fronts"
T'o the West:
119 Nightingale could
build an ample addition
toward the rear.
Despite dual "fronts,"
101 Raven Road has
ample room to build.
To the l=ast:
Despite being on a nar-
row lot, 113 Nightingale
features an addition -like
projection toward the
rear.
Dave and Kate Dentel
102 Raven Road
Stephens CityVa.22655
Junc 2016
Varianc-e:
SimilarHome- .�)29 Nluebnirci
Different let, same design,
different results:
In the same development, owners of a home
nearly identical to the Dentel property were
able to build a substantial addition.This home
at 229 Bluebird presumably was approved for
an expansion project because it was built to the
side, where setbacks are minimal.
Unfortunately for the Dentel property on Raven
Road, what would be considered the "side" is
tabled a second "front" (not pictured here).
Dave and Kate Dentel
102 Raven Load
Stephens City,Va.22655
,TullIc 2016
request for Zoning'V1ariwnc e:
Ne'v-1-iboA
9s_/ iJ'.'-_ ALA l
If granted the opportunity to expand our home, we hope to build in such a way that preserves tile character of
our innnc(hate lielgllborhood. Overall, our subdivision, Greenbrier Village, lacks a home owner's association, so
individual properties vary considerable 111 condlLlon, upkeep and appearance.
Our immediate neighborhood at Raven Road and Nightingalc Avenue, however, is very Nvell-uiaintali led. And
we feel we have good relationships 11*11-di our neighbors — which is one reason we decided to remain in our present
liome and try- to improve our property raider th:ul niuve. Consequently, we are taking great care that our design
ideas present a plcasault aesthetic that will enhance the immediate neighborhood aild perhaps even add value.
We are including design idea s niples for out- proposed addition below.
N1 IN P41 IN
Above: For the addition we envi-
sion a flat roof with a decorative
railing.
Above, night: The addition design
would feature several tali windows
and kneeboard siding.
Above: The
bump -out section
could contain
attractive built-in
storage.
Deft: We would
also like to build
a roof over the
existing patio.
Dave and Kate Dentel
102 Raven Road
Stephens Clty,Va.22655
a s a*.a -14
June 2016
Request for honing variance:
Detailed Overview
What do we want to do?
We would like to provide more living space, better
heating and a first -floor bathroom for Kate's elderly
parents, who are on a fixed income and need more
than their present 260 square feet plus an upstairs bed-
room to live in.
Why is this necessary?
We currently have only 1,732 square feet and one -
and -a -half baths in our house. The full bath has an
acrylic clawfoot tub that is difficult for Kate's 80 -year-
old mother to climb into. Going upstairs is hard on her
knees, and Kate's father has to take the stairs slowly due
to his atrial fibrillation. (And two toilets for four adults
just isn't working very well.) The living room ceiling
is vaulted, and consequently it is impossible to get it
warm enough for Kates parents in the winter (they use
space heaters in their rooms to augment the HVAC
heat); and the remaining first -floor space is open on
three sides.
Can't you alter the floorplan to accommodate
another bath?
The half -bath is situated in a hallway and could be
made into an awkward, walk-through bathroom that
would diminish the value of our home, but
a) It would not solve the need for more toilets;
b) It would require us to get rid of our present washer
and dryer to purchase a stackable unit;
c) It would require the floor space of the pantry, taking
away much-needed storage space and litterbox con-
tainment;
d) It would not add any much-needed square footage;
e) It would require extensive re -working of the bath-
room area, leaving four adults the use of one toilet
until the work was done;
f) It would require opening up a load-bearing wall;
g) Two plumbers have looked at it and said that there
is not enough depth to create a shower to code.
Can't you just move into a bigger house?
There are several constraints in this area, being:
a) We can't afford a home of the needed square footage
at present prices in the Stephens City area; we would
have to relocate to West Virginia to find an affordable
alternative;
b) Most available homes have just a half -bath on the
first floor, and bedrooms upstairs, which is not as con-
venient as what we have now;
c) We are already in the middle of a refinance, not
making it financially feasible to turn around the sell
the house, losing over $7,000 in closing fees; and
d) We love our neighbors and want to keep them, and
not have the two-way crapshoot of our possibly getting
bad neighbors as well as their getting bad neighbors.
e) We have several feral cats on the property that were
born under our shed. We have had them vetted, vacci-
nated and fixed and they live on our property, and we
provide food and. shelter for them. Relocating them
would be extremely difficult, if not impossible
Would it be good for the neighborhood?
The subdivision of Greenbrier Village is a mixture
of different styles and sizes. Houses of less than 1,000
square feet coexist side-by-side with footprints of
over 2,000 square feet; There are ranch -style homes,
split -foyers, split-levels, colonials and contemporary
Dave and Kate Dentel
102 Raven Road
Stephens City Va. 22655
?j4 mac? �F4.
June 20 f 6
R-(--,.,,q1jest for ni gr Variance:
"etailed C_;VP,_(7JI*CW--(20nU.-tIUed
salt -boxes, like ours. Some homes are well-maintained
and renovated, while others are shrouded in weeds,
have multiple vehicles up on blocks, missing shingles
and broken blinds. There is no HOA.
When we are gardening in our front yard, usually
someone (sometimes several people) will stop and say,
"I love what you've done to this place!" Our house was
bank -owned and needed a couple of thousand dol-
lars put into it before we could even get it appraised
when we bought it in 2009. Our desire is to stay put
and provide housing for Kate's parents where we are,
improving the character of the house over the time we
are here.
A house of our exact style has been added to ex-
tensively; however this lot has neighbors on three
sides whereas our house is on a corner, providing
two "fronts" from which to measure setbacks. We are
confident that our addition would look appealing to
our neighbors and passers-by. Too, being the second
house on Raven Road coming from Aylor Road, it adds
charm to the subdivision, and makes it seem more like
a neighborhood.
Above: The Dentel home as seen from Raven Road. Our pref-
erence was to build a 500 -square -foot addition just to the left
(north), but this is precluded by a 35 -foot setback.
Left: The east side of the Dentel home, where we hope to build
an addition --i{ the property here can be defined as a "side." We
will have to move the landscaping, of course.
Dave and Kate Dentel
102 Raven Road
Stephens CityVa.22655
Junc 2016
equest fog- 'r -J0111 -1g iariance
Act it o aDocumen- t Limn
We wish to thautk Frederick Countystaff {or their assistance and members of lice Board of %ortircg Appeals lot -
considering our case.
Dual Hardship
We are requesting a zoning variautec lot- our property at 102 Raven Road. We fuel iwe have a strong case for
claiming it hardship based on the tact tial, since ours is a corner lot, we lace setback restrletiorrs we otberlvise
would not icave encountered.
Aird though we realize that technically it is riot a consideration for the hoard, we would like to 111crition our
reason for wanting to build an addition: We wish to accommodate Date's elderly parents.
Specifically, Nve would like to add a ground floor suite of rooms drat includes a full balls. Currently our only lull
ball► is on Qre second floor. ITnfortunately, climbing the stairs is beconmig increasingly difficult for Mr. and Mrs
Wright. Aucl, with our home's present configuration, (here is no space to add an additional bath ori cilher floor.
Street Address. #102 Raven Road
•��j l—�
s£crtON ONE
tot 51
\130.00'
dtNN LW, nNCE
General area where
�r
S 04'29'44" E _
5.6 IRr
Dentels wish to build.
\3!T`.']a1iry�=y,__i
tea'
SHED
�
�
N,p00EN
lm
"front"
�a
VEC
Second along
`
_. , .: to
Nightingale Ave. man-
w
���"�
IiTO°Y
dates 35 -soot setbackx
.-. a
`` '`
°
/101
where Dentels could
tot 67
otherwise build.
A
Lot 68 Im
40.6 10,885 Sq. Ft. h
69
N 01 '47'00" W 69.70' IRF
RAVEN ROAD
60' R/W
Street Address. #102 Raven Road