HomeMy WebLinkAbout032-26 (CUP05-26-172FireHouseLLC) CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT #05-26
Fire House LLC and Barbara Singhas (Stephen Pettler POA)
Landscape Contracting Business
Staff Report for the Board of Supervisors
Prepared: November 5, 2026
Staff Contact: Amy Feltner, Planner
Executive Summary:
Meeting Schedule
Planning Commission: October 21, 2026 Action: Recommended Approval
Board of Supervisors: November 12, 2026 Action: Pending
Property Information
Property Identification Number (PIN) 52-A-287B
Address 171 Firehouse Lane
Magisterial District Back Creek
Acreage +/-5.00
Zoning & Present Land Use Zoning: RA (Rural Areas)
Land Use: Landscape Contracting Business
Adjoining Property Zoning & Present Land Use
North: RA (Rural Areas) District Land Use: Private school & residential
South: RA Land Use: Special event facility
East: RA Land Use: Agricultural/vacant
West : RA Land Use: Special event facility
Proposed Use
This is a request for a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to reestablish a revoked permit for
landscape contracting business in the RA (Rural Areas) Zoning District.
Page 2 of 7
Review Agency Comments:
Review Agency
Comment Date Comment Summary
Virginia Department of
Transportation (VDOT)
June 15, 2026 “VDOT has no comments on
the CUP.”
Frederick-Winchester Health
Department
July 9, 2026 No objection to the proposed
use of the property. “The
existing sewage disposal
system is designed for 8
employees for 8-hour shift &
40 field employees only. The
well is required to be
regulated by the Office of
Driving Water if the water is
used by 25 or more people for
60 or more days out of the
year.”
Frederick County (FC)
Inspections
August 27, 2026 Change of use (R use to B
use) permit is required for the
existing structure (house) &
site. At least one accessible
restroom and accessible van
parking space and accessible
access to the house shall be
provided. Asbestos
inspection, building plans,
and an approved site plan is
required for the change of use
permit. Commencement of
renovations before obtaining
permits shall be a violation of
Sec. 108.1 of the Virginia
Construction Code (VCC).
FC Fire Marshal August 25, 2026 Approved with conditions.
Above ground storage tanks
shall comply with Chapter 23
of the F.C. Fire Prevention
Code (FCFPC). Storage of
wood chips or other hogged
materials (mulch) shall
comply with FCFPC, Chapter
28. All occupied structures
for the purposes of business
Page 3 of 7
shall have portable fire
extinguishers as outlined in
the FCFPC.
FC Public Works June 12, 2026 “No comments from Public
Works. No proposed land
disturbance or changes to
grading or stormwater
management.”
FC GIS June 22, 2026 “No further road names or
addresses required.”
HRAB May 17, 2024 Recommends approval.
Requests the applicant create
a mixture of planting types
when screening the property.
Planning & Zoning:
Application Proposal:
This is a request to reestablish a revoked conditional use permit (CUP) for a landscape contracting
business in the RA (Rural Areas) Zoning District on +/-5.00-acres. The application proposed using
the existing office trailer for a maximum of five (5) regular employees that work at the site daily.
The hours of operation as proposed in the application are 6 a.m. – 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.
The business generally does not have customers on site.
There are approximately forty-five (45) employees (depending on seasonal needs) of which only
thirty (30) employees come to the site for work assignments. Only 20 employee vehicles will be
parked on site at any time; all other employees report directly to the job site. Supplies and materials
are typically obtained and transported by employees directly to the site, although some live
plantings are stored and weekly fuel delivery and trash pickup are scheduled. Employees will load
equipment and supplies early in the morning before leaving the property for the jobsite. After
completion of the jobs, they return to the site and unload, clean, service the equipment and vehicles.
There is an existing garage/shop on site where the equipment/vehicles are serviced.
The long-term plan is to utilize the existing dwelling that is currently located on site for an office.
Additionally, as the business grows, the ability to have sixty (60) employees at this location.
Site History:
A conditional use permit was approved on August 14, 2024, by the Frederick County Board of
Supervisors. A c ondition of approval at that time required submission and approval of a minor
site plan prior to the establishment of the use. On April 8, 2026, the Board of Supervisors
Page 4 of 7
revoked conditional use permit #03-24 due to the violation of said condition, as a site plan was
not approved. The same applicant is requesting a new conditional use permit to reestablish the
use.
Staff Analysis:
§165-304.02 of the Federick County Zoning Ordinance for Conditional Use Permits (CUP) states
that the Planning Commission and Board shall consider the following standards when considering
Conditional Use Permits:
A. The conditional use shall not tend to change the character and established pattern of
development of the area of the proposed use.
• The proposed use is permitted in the RA (Rural Area) District with an approved conditional
use permit. (§165-603.01). The property is located within the Round Hill Rural Community
Center and surrounded by other RA (Rural Area) zoned properties, which includes
Independent School of Winchester, Fox Meadow (special event facility) and single-family
detached residences. One goal of the Comprehensive Plan is to encourage appropriate
mixes of residential, commercial and business uses within the Rural Community Centers.
The property is zoned RA (Rural Area) and, if all conditions are adhered to, will not change
the character and established development of the area.
B. The conditional use shall be in harmony with and shall not adversely affect the use and
enjoyment of surrounding properties.
• The property is surrounded by other RA (Rural Area) zoned properties, which includes
institutional, agricultural, agritourism and single-family detached residences. The
proposed use will not adversely affect the use and enjoyment of the surrounding properties
if operated under the conditions specified.
C. The conditional use shall be in accord with the policies expressed in the Comprehensive Plan
of the County and with the intent of this chapter.
• The Comprehensive Plan identifies this area of the County as “rural” and located within
the Round Hill Rural Community. A goal of the Comprehensive Plan is to encourage
appropriate mixes of residential, commercial and business uses within the Rural
Community Centers
D. The conditional use shall not adversely affect the natural character and environment of the
County.
• No new structures are proposed, and if the operation is conducted inside an existing facility
as proposed and in accordance with all conditions, the proposal would not adversely affect
the nature and character of the environment.
E. The conditional use permit shall be approved only if adequate facilities, roads, safe access and
drainage are provided.
Page 5 of 7
• The property is accessed via an existing private driveway located at 171 Old Firehouse
Lane.
F. The conditional use shall conform with all applicable regulations of the district in which it is
located.
• The Zoning Ordinance provides additional regulations for outdoor storage in §165-808.02.
The additional regulation for specific uses is as follows:
o When permitted, the outdoor storage or processing shall be completely screened
from the view of road and street ROW and from surrounding properties by a six-
foot-tall opaque fence, wall, berm or evergreen screen.
o Outdoor storage surface areas shall consist of asphalt, concrete, stone, gravel or any
other impervious surface approved by the Zoning Administrator.
o Outdoor storage and processing shall not be permitted in any required front setback
yard.
Conditions of Approval:
Should the Board of Supervisors find the landscape contracting business use to be appropriate, the
Planning Commission would suggest the following conditions for the CUP:
1. All review agency comments and requirements shall be complied with at all times.
2. A site plan shall be submitted to and approved by Frederick County within ninety (90)
days of approval of this conditional use permit. The Zoning Administrator may grant one
additional 30-day extension if the site plan is submitted and under review by applicable
agencies but not yet approved. All improvements required by the site plan shall be
completed, installed and inspected by the Zoning Administrator prior to the establishment
of the use. All improvements required by the site plan shall be installed within six (6)
months of the approval of the site plan.
3. In the event the site plan is not approved by the Zoning Administrator in the time allotted
in condition 2 above, the conditional use permit will be immediately void.
4. All outdoor storage of vehicles (operating or inoperable), landscape contracting
equipment, trailers, fueling tanks, nursery stock and other landscaping raw materials shall
be completely screened from the view of road and street ROW and from surrounding
properties by a six-foot-tall opaque fence, wall, berm or evergreen screen. In addition,
both a opaque fence and plantings are installed on the North and East side of the parcel.
5. The business is limited to 45 employees; no more than 25 employee vehicles are
permitted on the property at any one time.
6. Hours of operation for the site shall be limited to 6:00 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily with the exceptions for
emergency inclement weather services (snow removal and storm damage remediation).
7. A business licenses and zoning review form is required from the Commissioner of
Page 6 of 7
Revenue office within 365-days of approval of this conditional use permit, and annually
thereafter as required by the Commissioner of Revenue.
8. One monument style sign is permitted on the property, not to exceed 50 square feet in
sign area and 12 feet in height.
9. Any change in the use for which the conditional use permit was granted shall require a
new conditional use permit (CUP).
Planning Commission Summary & Action from the October 21, 2026 Meeting:
The Planning Commission held a public hearing during their regular meeting on October 21, 2026.
The Planning Commission noted that the business is currently operating following the April 2026
revocation and continues to operate at this facility. The Zoning Administrator has requested
continuance within the General District Court pending the outcome of this application. The next
scheduled appearance is November 24, 2026.
The Planning Commission questioned the condition requiring approval of the site plan within
ninety (90) days. Staff explained that a site plan approval would be needed in ninety (90) days
otherwise condition 3 would immediately void the conditional use permit.
The Planning Commission asked for clarification of the limit of forty (40) field employees
permitted on the site. The existing sewage disposal system is limited by the Virginia Department
of Health with a “limit of 8 employees for 8-hour shift & forty (40) field employees.” The business
may have other employees at other locations not included in this total. The Planning Commission
questioned the hours of operation and compared the current request with the conditions set for the
previous conditional use permit. The hours of operation also included weekends for snow
emergencies, snow plowing, and storm damage. The current application did not include the
request, and the applicant acknowledge their desire to include that condition. It was also noted
that 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. were the preferred hours of operation.
The Planning Commission inquired as to the completeness of the site plan which was submitted
under the previous conditional use permit. Staff acknowledged that the sketch plan provided with
the application was the site plan submitted under the old conditional use permit and that the
changes necessary would not be substantial but nevertheless, changes were required. The previous
site plan submitted was not approved. The Planning Commission noted that the complaints
received from adjacent residents included numerous inoperable vehicles. Staff explained the
applicant would be required to provide a site plan showing the location and areas of equipment
storage. Additionally, the ordinance requires screening of any outdoor storage areas.
The Planning Commission noted the fueling area and the office trailer currently in use on the site.
Staff stated the Building Inspection department and the Fire Marshal’s office will address the
permitting and approval of these items at the site plan submission and building permitting stage of
the project.
The Planning Commission addressed the applicant to ensure he understood the conditions, accepts
Page 7 of 7
the conditions and understands the ramifications of not meeting those conditions. The applicant
agrees with the conditions and felt them to be reasonable, understands the costs, and understands
the time frame. The only concern was the time necessary for the various agencies to provide
comments or satisfy any corrections necessary. The applicant acknowledged the upgraded buffer
requirement along the existing established residential uses. The applicant would prefer to have it
completely screened to reduce conflict between neighbors.
One (1) neighbor spoke to the commitment from the applicant on the promise to make the site
compliant. He addressed the trash, stored tires, and junk that he viewed daily.
The Planning Commission recommended adding the following recommendations:
1. Hours of operation for the site shall be limited to 6:00 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily with the
exceptions for emergency inclement weather services (snow removal and storm damage
remediation).
2. All improvements required by the approved site plan be completed within six (6) months
after the site plan approval.
The Planning Commission recommended approval of the proposed conditional use permit
application with the additional recommendations. (10-0, Kerns, Kozel, and Lamana were absent).
Following a public hearing, staff are seeking a decision by the Board of Supervisors on this
CUP application.
10/21/2026
11/12/2026
09/25/26
2368 Cedar Creek Grade, Winchester 22602
172 Firehouse LLC by Tyler Stine (Jun 3, 2026 15:45:59 EDT)
172 Firehouse LLC by Tyler Stine (Jun 3, 2026 15:45:59 EDT)
Barbara Singhas (Jun 3, 2026 22:58:39 EDT)
STEPHEN L. PETTLER, JR.
MEMBER
21 S. Loudoun Street
Winchester, VA 22601
(540) 667-1266
(540) 667-1312 fax
pettler@harrison-johnston.com
sproul@harrison-johnston.com
www.harrison-johnston.com
MEMORANDUM
July 29, 2026
TO: AMY FELTNER
FROM: STEVE PETTLER
RE: 172 FIREHOUSE / SINGHAS CUP APPLICATION
Amy, the following is intended to be the narrative statement of the nature and operation of A Cut Above Landscape
Group, LLC at the 171 Firehouse Lane property.
The new owner of the business (A Cut Above Landscape Group, LLC) acquired the assets of the former business
operating at the site in October, 2025. It is a landscaping services company. There are currently approximately 45
employees (it changes depending on seasonal needs). Of these less than thirty (30) come to the site for work assignments
each day and no more than 20 employee vehicles are parked at the site at any one time. Only one (1) employee spends
most of each business day at the site (admin / bookkeeper) with all others working off-site most of the time after they
are issued their assignments, vehicles and equipment for the day. At most, the business has five (5) employees working
on site at any one time, and of these five, they are in the office trailer doing bids / paperwork / making phone calls.
Business hours are 6 am to 8 pm, Monday-Friday. Generally, the business does not have customers on site. Supplies
and materials are generally obtained and transported by employees, so there are few deliveries or vendors on site. There
is a weekly fuel delivery and garbage pick-up to the site.
Fleet vehicles, trailers, equipment, tools, parts, supplies, and live plants are intended to be stored in the areas designated
on the sketch submitted with the application. Employees will load equipment and supplies in the early morning before
leaving the property for job-sites. After completion of jobs, they return to the site and unload, clean, and service
equipment and vehicles. The site contains a shop building where equipment and vehicle servicing and repair occurs, as
needed.
There is currently an office trailer on the site, and it is intended to be maintained as the office where the employees will
work for the foreseeable future.
It is the expectation of the new owner to grow the business slowly over the next few years. The prior business operations
have been reorganized and numerous internal operational changes made which are intended to allow for incremental
growth. It is expected that no more than sixty (60) employees will ever be employed at this location (the business has
another location also), with the office staff remaining as it is currently.
The long-term plan is to relocate the office staff to the house at the property. This transition is not a priority at this time
given the need to stabilize current business operations and focus resources on work required to comply with the site
plan and investment in business growth before investing in the house so that it can be transitioned to office use. It is
expected that this may occur within 2-3 years, however, we ask that the application be approved with the intention of
using the house for office space in the future.