CEA_11-18-10_Meeting_Minutes•
MEETING MINUTES
OF THE
FREDERICK COUNTY CONSERVATION EASEMENT AUTHORITY
Held in the Executive Session Room of the Frederick County Administration Building at 107 North
Kent Street in Winchester, Virginia on November 18, 2010 at 8:00 a.m.
PRESENT: Diane Kearns, Chairman; Robert Solenberger; and Charles Triplett, Planning Commission
Liaison.
ABSENT: Ritchie Wilkins, Vice - Chairman; Jim Lawrence, Treasurer; John Marker; Elaine Cain; Todd
Lodge; and Gene Fisher, Board of Supervisors Liaison,
STAFF PRESENT: Eric R. Lawrence, CEA Secretary; and Bev Dellinger, Secretary 111.
PUBLIC MEETING:
1. September 22, 2010 Meeting Minutes
There was not a quorum present; therefore, the minutes of September 22, 2010 were not acted
upon.
2. 2010 Frederick County Comprehensive Plan
a. Rural Areas Section Update
Chairman Kearns stated that the Rural Areas section of the Comp Plan has been written and it's
ready to go through the public process. Mr. Lawrence said it should be adopted by February.
Chairman Kearns is pleased with the way it has turned out. The format now is much more
succinct and people can understand what they're reading. It doesn't change anything, but it
delineates some of the concepts that we've been trying to get across. One of the policies is
"Support Voluntary Land Preservation Tools ", which mirrors what this Committee is doing.
Mr. Lawrence stated this clarifies what is already in the Rural Areas Section of the Comp Plan.
It's not any new information; it's gathering everything we've done and talked about as a
community for a number of years. The Comp Plan has not been updated since the CEA was
created.
Chairman Kearns stated that the entire Comp Plan is being updated using the same format.
3. Update on Power Line Projects, as Applicable
a. Potomac Allegheny Transmission Highline (PATH)
b. Dominion Power's Rebuild
Mr. Lawrence stated as far as PATH goes, nothing has changed since the last time the
Committee met. The County previously opposed PATH and still is opposed to PATH. Mr.
• Lawrence continued that the Board's Resolution said that Frederick County doesn't appear to be
getting any benefit from it. It's impacting our land values and our rural preservation lots and it
Conservation Easement Authority Page - 149 -
November 18, 2010
shouldn't be allowed. Also, the Board feels that PATH keeps holding public meetings in odd
places; they went to Handley High School. A citizen spoke at one of the Board meetings saying
that a lot of the older population of the County doesn't want to come into the City. So holding a
public meeting for PATH at Handley discourages people from attending. The Board of
Supervisors said when you hold a meeting, make sure it's in the County, like James Wood High
School.
The rebuild, which was presented to the Board of Supervisors last week, is completely different.
In Mr. Lawrence's perception, PATH has never said anything about the rebuild. Mr.
Solenberger asked if there's any common ownership. Mr. Lawrence stated he thinks there could
be at some point, but the way rebuild is coming forward, it's Dominion Resources and they're
rebuilding their existing corridor. There's an existing 500 kV that runs through northern
Frederick County which, indirectly, PATH wants to parallel, but Dominion owns that existing
500 kV. Dominion Resources is clear in saying they are not PATH.
Chairman Kearns asked about the concept that because of the greater capacity, Dominion could
carry more and, therefore, reduce the necessity for PATH. Mr. Lawrence responded that
Dominion wouldn't commit to that, but there's certainly perceptions that if you're creating
greater capacity, do we need PATH? That's probably an argument that anti -PATH and other
organizations will use to fight PATH. One thing that Dominion pointed out last week at the
Board meeting was they said they're replacing their existing corridor. We'll get more power to
flow through it, but that's not the intent. The intent is to replace an aging system.
0 4. Fundraising Efforts
a. GIFT — G ive S for F rederick's T omorrow
Chairman Kearns said she has made some contacts with people about participating in the
program. She talked with Julie Armel of the Museum of Shenandoah Valley and they are
completely in support of the program. Ms. Armel said that any event the Conservation Easement
Authority holds, the Museum of Shenandoah Valley would like to participate.
5. Overview on Tax Benefits of Conservation Easement Donations
Mr. Lawrence stated that he attended a conference last month where he was on a panel with
Kevin Schmidt, who's the State PDR person we've dealt with, and Rex Linfield, who's with
Piedmont Environmental Council (PEC). PEC presented an excellent power point as far as
information on conservation easements and the tax benefits of donations. Mr. Lawrence handed
out to members a copy of that power point presentation. Mr. Lawrence stated that he's going to
tailor the presentation, crediting PEC, and make it available on our CEA webpage.
Chairman Kearns read some notes and comments that Ms. Cain provided. One item to note is,
"Conservation easements can be placed on property by the Executor or Trustee after death. If
estate tax exemption returns to $1,000,000 in 2011, this could provide significant estate tax
savings." Another item is, "Virginia is no longer accepting or approving applications for state
land preservation credits. Early next year would be the perfect time to submit these applications.
Then sales could occur as soon as approved by the State. They set an annual limit for approval
of $50,000,000. Back in July, one individual placed a high value conservation easement and
gobbled up any room that they had remaining for 2010."
Conservation Easement Authority Page - 150 -
November 18, 2010
•
6. Nomination for New Member to Replace Jim Lawrence
Chairman Kearns stated that she, Mr. Fisher and Mr. Jim Lawrence talked about what sectors of
the population would fit into place with the Committee. Chairman Kearns thought someone in
real estate would be a good segue. Mr. Lawrence suggested someone in the engineering
community. Chairman Kearns stated that hopefully by the next meeting, someone will have
cone up with a name.
7. Next Meeting Date
It was decided that the next meeting will be held in January 2011.
8. Other
Mr. Triplett told members that now when you file for tax relief in land use, you have to present a
farm schedule and a copy of your tax return, which you didn't have to do before this year. Mr.
Triplett thinks this is a wonderful idea because that will weed out three, five, fifteen and twenty
acre farms that don't have a farm commodity or any income from the farm.
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 8:35 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
•
C .f2Q.�c �PCi�,
Diane Kearns, Chairman
Eric R. Lawrence, CEA Secretary
•
Conservation Easement Authority Page - 151 -
November 18, 2010