September 23, 1981 Regular Meeting413
A Regular Meeting of the Frederick County Board of Supervisors was held
on September 23, 1981, at 7:00 P.M., in the Board of Supervisors Meeting
Room, 9 Court Square, Winchester, Virginia.
PRESENT S. Roger Koontz, Chairman; Will L. Owings, Vice - Chairman;
William H. Baker; Rhoda W. Maddox; R. Thomas Malcolm and Kenneth Y. Stiles.
CALL TO ORDER
The Chairman called the meeting to order.
INVOCATION
The invocation was delivered by the Reverend James Messner of the
Relief -Hites United Methodist Church.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Stiles stated that he had an item that he would like to have
referred to the Finance Committee.
Upon motion made by R. Thomas Malcolm, seconded by Kenneth Y. Stiles and
passed unanimously, the agenda was adopted with the above amendment.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mrs. Maddox requested the following corrections in the minutes of August
26, 1981:
Page 5, the vote on the School Board appointment of Lewis Costello is
not recorded.
Page 7, third paragraph from the bottom, the word "gunshot" should read
"gunshop ".
Page 15, second line, the word "my" should read "by"
Mr. Stiles requested the following changes in the minutes of August 26,
1981:
Page 8, the last paragraph, the last name of the Forester for Westvaco
is spelled "Vorbaugh ".
Page 9, second paragraph, Mr. Kline is spelled "Cline ".
Upon motion made by William H. Baker, seconded by Kenneth Y. Stiles and
passed unanimously, the minutes of August 26, 1981 and September 9, 1981,
Regular meetings, were approved as amended.
APPOINTMENT OF AT -LARGE MEMBER ON THE PLANNING COMMISSION
TABLED
Mr. Malcolm stated that he had contacted Mr. Langdon Gordon, whose term
expires on the Planning Commission on October 31, 1981, inasmuch as he is
from Shawnee District, and that Mr. Gordon had stated that he was not
interested in being reappointed to the Planning Commission. Mr. Malcolm
414
further stated that inasmuch as we have received only 1 application for this
appointment, that being a Mr. Light, whom he had contacted by phone, but was
not present at tonight's meeting, therefore he would like to have this
appointment readvertised and tabled until the meeting of October 14, 1981.
Upon motion made by R. Thomas Malcolm, seconded by Kenneth Y. Stiles an
passed unanimously, the Board of Supervisors of the County of Frederick,
Virginia, does herein table any action on the at -large member to the Planning
Commission until the October 14, 1981 meeting of this Board.
DR. MURIEL BROWN APPOINTED TO THE SHENANDOAH AREA AGENCY ON
AGING - APPROVED
Mr. Owings stated that Mrs. Shryock from his district was no longer
eligible to serve on this Board and that Dr. Muriel Brown of Middletown was
willing to serve.
Upon motion made by Will L. Owings, seconded by Kenneth Y. Stiles and
passed unanimously, the Board of Supervisors of the County of Frederick,
Virginia, does herein appoint Dr. Muriel Brown to the Shenandoah Area Agency
on Aging, said term to commence on October 1, 1981 and terminate on October
1, 1984.
FRENCH KIRK REAPPOINTED TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION FROM
SHAWNEE DISTRICT - APPROVED
Upon motion made by R. Thomas Malcolm, seconded by Will L. Owings and
passed unanimously, the Board of Supervisors of the County of Frederick,
Virginia, does herein reappoint Mr. French Kirk to the Planning Commission
from Shawnee District for a four year term, said term to commence on October
4, 1981 and terminate on October 4, 1985.
REQUEST THAT THE APPLICATION FORMS FOR VARIOUS COUNTY
BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS BE CHANGED - APPROVED
Mr. Stiles noted that on the applications filled out by County
residents for various Boards and Commissions that No. 2 asked the Age, Race
and Sex of the applicant, and he did not feel this was proper.
Upon motion made by Kenneth Y. Stiles, seconded by William H. Baker and
passed unanimously, the Board of Supervisors of the County of Frederick,
Virginia, does herein approve the deleting of the words age, race and sex of
the current application forms used in the selection of members on the various
County Boards and Commissions.
QUESTIONS REFERRED TO THE FINANCE COMMITTEE WITH REFERENCE
TO TOTAL COST OF JAMES WOOD RIDGE CAMPUS
415
Mr. Stiles presented the six following questions and requested that they
be referred to the Finance Committee and a report made back to the Board at
the October 14, 1981 meeting:
1. Money for building and equipment in construction budget.
2. Equipment and books, etc. purchased through regular operating
budget, including that reimbursed by state and including money spent
from school lunch budget.
3. Other expenses in regular budget, including outside work -
Sanitation Authority hook -up fees, etc.
4. Obligations contracted but not paid for or budgeted in '82 year
including Sanitation Authority, Architect, etc.
5. Equipment, books, etc. still needed but not yet budgeted - library,
athletic, etc.
6. Cost of replacing equipment in other schools for equipment
transferred to Ridge Campus and any expenses incurred by agencies of
the government other than the School Board, i.e. the Highway
Department, Recreation Department, etc.
REYNOLDS STORE FIRE COMPANY REQUEST FOR IMPACT FEES
APPROVED
Upon motion made by Rhoda W. Maddox, seconded by Will L. Owings and
passed unanimously, the Board of Supervisors of the County of Frederick,
Virginia, does herein approve the unanimous recommendation of the Parks and
Recreation Commission that $18,500.00 of the Gainesboro District Impact Funds
be released for development of a community park to be located at the Reynolds
Store Fire Company as outlined in the following agreement:
Cost of Maintaining Reynolds Store Playground
All figures are based on the fact that we presently maintain the
property at Gainesboro Elementary School during the summer season.
Figures are based on a maintenance program which will consist of a visit
once every 14 days between March 15 and October 15 of each year. Maintenance
during the "off season" will be performed on a as needed basis.
Raintenance that will be performed will be mowing and general inspection
of the facility and equipment. The equipment needed to perform the
maintenance will be one riding mower, one push mower and one trimmer.
Below is a complete cost estimate of maintaining the facility at
Reynolds Store:
Miles traveled March 15 - October 15
320
at .50 per mile
$160.00 Annually
Man Hours (Two Men)
30 minutes additional road time
and one hour to perform maintenance.
Cost of man hours $ 11.45
Times per year 16
$183.20 Total
416
Cost of Operating Equipment
$ 4.00 per visit
16 Vists per year
$ 64.00 Total
Total cost of maintenance of facility per year would be $407.20 plus any
replacements that may be needed.
A G R E E M E N T
This Agreement, made and entered into this day of ,
1981, by and between Frederick County Board of Supervisors (Frederick County
Parks and Recreation Department), party of the first part, hereinafter
sometimes referred to as "Department ", and the Reynolds Store Volunteer Fire
Company, party of the second part, hereinafter sometimes referred to as
"Company ".
WHEREAS, the Frederick County Parks and Recreation Department recogniz(
the need for the development of a recreational facility in the Northwestern
part of Frederick County, Virginia; and
WHEREAS, the Reynolds Store Volunteer Fire Company is the owner of
certain real estate located in the Northwestern part of Frederick County and
is agreeable to have a portion of that real estate used for recreational
purposes for the general public.
NOW THEREFORE, THIS AGREEMENT, WITNESSETH: That for and in con-
sideration of the mutual benefits to be derived and the desire of the parties
hereto to meet and fulfill the recreational needs of the general public of
Frederick County and further, in consideration of the premises and the mutual
covenants and promises contained herein, the parties do hereby agree as
follows:
1. Department hereby agrees to develop through the use of impact funds
specifically designated for Gainesboro District, a community park located at
Reynolds Store Fire Hall to include a tot lot and a playground area for older
children which will include equipment mutually agreed upon by the Frederick
County Recreation Department and Gainesboro District Board Member appointed
committee.
2. Frederick County Parks and Recreation Department hereby agrees to
maintain the said tot lot and playground for older children on a year round
basis.
3. It is agreed that the tot lot and the older children's playground
will be an unscheduled playground open to anyone, provided however, that the
rules governing the use of the tot lot and the older children's playground
x-17
will be formulated and enforced by the Board of Directors of Company.
Department shall have the opportunity for imput in the formulation of the
rules. The rules once formulated will be posted in appropriate areas.
Failure to comply with the formulated rules may result in the termination of
the privilege of the use of these facilities for such periods of time as the
Company Board shall determine.
4. Department shall be responsible for the replacement of equipment
damaged as a result of normal wear and tear and not covered by warranty.
5. Frederick County Parks and Recreation Department hereby accepts and
agrees to accept the responsibility for liability coverage for the playground
area.
FREDERICK COUNTY PARKS AND
RECREATION DEPARTMENT
REYNOLDS STORE VOLUNTEER
FIRE COMPANY
BY
President
IMPACT FEE POLICY - APPROVED
Mr. Stiles stated that when this matter was discussed by the Board it
was specifically requested that consideration be given to developing a
policy that would first of all limit the application for use of these fees to
registered non - profit groups, that secondly the responsibility for
maintenance would be left in the hands of the group that was applying for and
receiving the funds, and thirdly that a determination be made with regard to
liability coverage. Mr. Stiles inquired as to whether or not such a policy
was presented to the Recreation Commission for its consideration.
Mr. Cheely stated that the policy that was presented was primarily the
one that was made up by the Recreation Commission and the staff.
Mr. Stiles inquired as to whether or not the request of the Board was
presented to the Recreation Commission as an option.
Mr. Cheely stated that the draft, as you see it, was what was presented
taken on an individual basis. It was not presented that maintenance would be
provided by each group and it was not ever given to me in the form of a
motion from this Board, and that the Board would only recognize non - profit
groups. Mr. Cheely further stated that the three items that were brought out
by Mr. Stiles were discussed at each of the meetings that took place, but
41 €J
that he was not aware these three items had to be included in the final
agreement.
Mr. Stiles stated that the maintenance cost of this $75,000 of Capital
Improvements concerned him greatly and if the County was going to maintain
one, the bottom line is that the County is going to maintain them all, so
basically we are writing a blank check for the maintenance cost on the
$75,000 worth of Capital Improvements.
Mr. Cheely stated that the Commission felt that each situation would be
considered on its own merit and that there would be an overall policy to deal
with all types of groups.
Mr. Owings stated that he felt the impact money should be spent in the
district in which it was generated and further that he felt the Recreation
Commission should realize that the money for recreation is going to be
limited and if it becomes necessary to divert "x" number of dollars to these
smaller parks then the maintenance on your two larger parks is going to be
hurt and he feels this must be realized. He further stated that he is in
favor of the Reynolds Store and any other area that wants to spend the impact
money, but when it comes to the maintenance costs he didn't feel the County
should be expected to pick up this additional costs.
Mr. Malcolm asked Mr. Boyd, President of the Reynolds Fire Company, if
his group would have been willing to accept this impact money with a
condition that there would have been no maintenance costs involved.
Mr. Boyd replied that they would have seriously had to consider this
before making a decision. He felt the people in his area had been paying
taxes, that have helped pay for recreation throughout Frederick County. He
further stated that he felt the people in the Reynolds Store area need to be
recognized as well as other outlying areas in this County as being part of
the County and having the County respond to these areas, and that this
response needs to go outside of just impact money.
Mr. Malcolm questioned the situation of someone coming before the Board
requesting impact money to build a tot lot in the middle of a subdivision
that is in an area that is served handily by a preexisting recreational
facility.
Mr. Boyd stated that it was because of a situation such as this, that
this matter should go through the Parks and Recreation Commission.
Mr. Stiles stated that at one time it was discussed, as a possibility,
that a third larger park may be built in the western part of the County and
� I-
that this was a concern of the Planning Commission as they felt this needed
to be addressed before the County started establishing a lot of small parks
in this same area.
Mr. Cheely stated there would be a 3 or 4 step process for a group to
follow in order for them to receive any impact monies.
Mr. Stiles stated that the Planning Commission felt that action should
be forthcoming in the very near future to phase out impact fees.
Mr. Baker stated that it was his understanding that the final word on
any of these monies being spent, from the impact fund, would have to come
from the Board, was this not true.
The Board concurred that it was.
Upon motion made by William H. Baker, seconded by Rhoda W. Maddox and
passed unanimously, the Recreational Impact Fee Policy was approved as
submitted.
Recreational Impact Fee Policy
Objective
To provide a means by which nonprofit groups and organizations can apply for
impact funds for recreation facilities.
Policy
I. The Frederick County Parks and Recreation Commission will develop
advisory committees to be established in each magisterial district to
transmit to the Parks and Recreation Department the parks and recreation
needs and wishes of the residents within the district and to provide
additional information on population characteristics for use of impact
funds, which may not be available otherwise.
A. Prior to making a decision on a planning or development matter within
a district, the Parks and Recreation Department will ascertain the
position of the advisory committee with respect to the impact fees
request before the Parks and Recreation Department.
B. There will be one committee per magisterial district appointed by the
Recreation Commission member from the respective district. No
interested group should be unrepresented because of an arbitrary
member limit and all geographic areas of the district shall be
represented. Some of the organizations that might be represented on
a typical committee could be: PTA, Teens, Ruritan Club, etc.
C. The appointments will be for a period not to exceed two years so that
fresh ideas are the rule, not the exception.
D. Each committee will be appointed and meet on a need basis as each
impact fee request is received.
E. Organization structure may be determined by each committee, however,
there must be a chairman to call the meetings, set agendas, and
preside. The Commission member shall chair the committee in his /her
district.
F. The following is an outline of the areas of responsibilities that the
staff and Recreation Commission should be aware of when dealing with
the impact fee committees.
1. Parks and Recreation Commission Responsibilities
420
a. Each Recreation Commission member will appoint committees and
determine that membership is representative of his /her
district.
b. To request advice on specific uses for impact fees.
c. To review and consider the impact fee committee
recommendations and requests.
2. Staff Responsibilities
a. To send out notices of impact fee committee meetings.
b. Provide available information and materials to the committees
as requested by the commission members.
c. To attend committee meetings when requested by the
commission.
Il. In order to achieve the lonq -range objectives of this department in
providing for the ordinary growth and maintenance of the parks system and
to meet the present and future needs of the citizenry in terms of impact
fees, the Parks and Recreation Department does herein establish a
planning process incorporating the principles listed below:
A. Plans must be based on a set of objectives derived from data and
information obtained through methods of a described set of policies
developed by the staff, approved by the Parks and Recreation
Commission, and adopted by the Board of Supervisors.
B. Procedures have been established for insuring maximum citizenry input
before and during preparation of plans, as outlined in letters A thru
F.
C. Plans must be submitted to the Parks and Recreation staff at a
pre- submission conference.
D. Plans must come to the Parks and Recreation staff with the
endorsement of the impact fee committee from the appropriate
magisterial district and the endorsement of the commission member and
board member from that district.
E. The Planning staff and Parks and Recreation staff will then review
the plans for completeness and conformance and submit them to the
Parks and Recreation Commission for endorsement.
F. The plan will then go to the Board of Supervisors and monies would be
released to the Parks and Recreation Department for the development
of the park land.
III. In considering use of impact funds, the following factors will be
evaluated prior to forwarding the commission's recommendation to the
Board:
A. The group requesting the monies
1. Eligibility will be limited to nonprofit groups or civic
organizations or community interest groups.
B. Socio- economic factors
1. Population characteristics of movement, mobility, age, income,
working habits.
2. Leisure interests that pertain to neighborhoods, communities, and
planning districts both existing and projected in the future.
C. Environmental factors
1. The environmental impact of any proposed recreational site will
be investigated to determine if there will be any adverse or
beneficial factors which could have an effect on the site. The
42_1
following are some of the environmental factors that will be
researched for each project:
a. General topography
b. Soils
c. Water resources
d. Flora and fauna
e. Access
f. Existing structures
g. Historical and archeological
h. Adjacent land uses
i. Air quality
j. Noise level
k. Weather
2. The following organizations may be consulted during the site
evaluation:
a. Public Health Department
b. Environmental groups
c. Historical societies
d. Extension Office
e. Soil Conservation Office
f. State Water Control Board
g. State Division of Forestry
h. Commission of Game and Inland Fisheries
i. Private and public recreation organizations
j. Citizen or resident organizations
k. Special interest groups
I. Planning Commission
D. Present park facilities and usage
E. Special requirements for the handicapped
F. National, State, and Regional plans
G. Existing and projected private and public facilities
H. County development plans
I. Legal agreements when dealing with nonprofit or civic organizations
or community interest groups.
J. Insurance coverage when dealing with outside agencies and community
interest groups
K. Maintenance
1. To be outlined in a comprehensive manner pertaining to each
specific project and supported by the Board of Supervisors prior
to approval of any acquisition or development.
L. Security
M. Repair and replacement
N. Scheduling of facility
O. Ceiling on monies to be appropriated
CHANGE IN PARKS AND RECREATION BY -LAWS - APPROVED
It had been recommended by the County Administrator and the Parks and
Recreation Commission concurred that the official number on the Parks and
Recreation Committee be changed from 10 to 9 to reflect the change in the
status of the Board of Supervisor member to that of a non - voting liaison.
42 G
Upon motion made by William H. Baker, seconded by Rhoda W. Maddox and
passed unanimously, the number on the Parks and Recreation Commission is
hereby changed from 10 to 9.
Mr. Stiles inquired as to whether this had been researched in the
minutes as to whether or not the Board had acted on this at an earlier date.
Mr. Cheely stated that the only change he could find in the minutes was
the change in the process for the selection of the 2 student members.
RECESS
Mr. Stiles stated that for the record he would like to state that in
reference to the policy on Recreational Impact Fee that just because
something is done one time it does not set a precedent and does not
necessarily mean that it will happen this way again.
REGIONAL WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT - DISCUSSED
Mr. Koontz stated that he would like to invite the City Council to the
Board Meeting on October 14, 1981 to discuss the regional wastewater
treatment plant.
Mr. Stiles requested that the County Planning Commission also be invited
to attend this meeting.
The Board agreed to these two requests.
Mr. Owings stated that he would like to know how much had been spent to
date on this project and how much more the County is committed to spend.
Mr. Baker asked if the Planning Commission had ever been involved in
this matter.
Mr. Stiles replied, not for ten seconds.
Mr. Koontz stated that the Planning Commission had never asked to be
involved.
Mr. Baker stated that it would occur to him that the County was
involving theirselves in a capital facility situation, and with the long
range plans the County has in mind, that he felt the Planning Commission
should certainly be involved in any preliminary discussions. He further
stated that the Board had agreed to have planning sessions with the Planning
Commission, and this had not materialized and he felt this was an error. Mr.
Baker made a motion that this situation with the Frederick - Winchester Service
Authority be referred to the Planning Commission for their appropriate input,
and in particular, the subcommittee of Capital Facilities and then brought
back to the Board.
423
Mr. Stiles seconded this for the purpose of discussion. He stated that
he agreed with this, but because of the time schedule involved he didn't feel
there would be enough time to get this done.
Mr. Horne stated that he felt the Planning Commission would not make a
recommendation inasmuch as they do not have enough of information to make a
recommendation, but that they would like to be brought up to date on this
project, and further that the Planning Commission does need to be included in
the discussions on this project.
Mr. Sam Lehman appeared before the Board and stated that in accordance
with a letter received from a representative of the EPA, in his opinion, Bob
Solenberger, as Chairman of the Frederick - Winchester Service Authority, could
sign this grant without prior approval of the two jurisdictions.
Mr. Koontz stated that Mr. Solenberger had agreed that he would not sign
without receiving prior approval of the two jurisdictions.
Mr. Malcolm stated that it was his understanding that the Board would
not be asked to make any decisions regarding the regional plant at the
October 14th meeting in order that a letter could be postmarked by 9:00 the
next morning, was this correct.
Mr. White stated that it was.
Mr. Horne stated that Mr. White and Mr. Jones would be invited to the
Planning Commission's first meeting in October to discuss the regional
plant.
Mr. Baker withdrew his motion and Mr. Stiles withdrew his second.
For. Koontz stated that at the present time the County buys their water
supply from the City and pay whatever price they charge us, and one of the
conditions of this agreement was that the City would sell water to the water
system of the Service Authority so that the Service Authority would be free
to sell to the County and to the City on an equal basis.
AN ORDINANCE EXEMPTING PURCHASES OF ARTIFICIAL OR PROPANE
GAS. WOOD. COAL OR HOME HEATING OIL USED FOR DOMESTIC
ES
Upon motion made by William H. Baker, seconded by Kenneth Y. Stiles and
passed unanimously, the following ordinance was approved:
BE IT ORDAINED by the Board of Supervisors of the County of
Frederick, Virginia, that effective October 1, 1981 and pursuant to Sections
58 -441.6 and 58- 441.49:3 of the Code of Virginia of 1950, as amended,
purchases of artificial or propane gas, wood, coal or home heating oil by an
424
individual purchaser for other than business, commercial or industrial
purposes are hereby exempted from the one percent (1 %) local option sales and
use tax.
Adopted by the Board of Supervisors on the 23 day of September 1981.
Mr. Stiles inquired as to when the Board would be interviewing for the
Director of Inspections.
Mr. White stated that he hoped to have this set up in the next two
weeks.
UPON MOTION DULY MADE, SECONDED AND PASSED UNANIMOUSLY, IT
IS ORDERED THAT THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS DO NOW ADJOURN.
hairman, o rd of ervisoY Clerk, Board of Supervisors