January 08, 2003 Work Session
388
A Budget Worksession of the Frederick County Board of Supervisors (Board) and the
Frederick County Finance Committee (Committee) was held at 6:00 P.M., in the Board of
Supervisors' Meeting Room, County Administration Building, 107 North Kent Street, Winchester,
Virginia.
PRESENT
Chairman Richard C. Shickle; Vice Chairman W. Harrington Smith, Jr.; Robert M. Sager;
Margaret B. Douglas; Sidney A. Reyes; Gina A. Forrester; and Lynda J. Tyler.
STAFF PRESENT
County Administrator John R. Riley, Jr.; Assistant County Administrator Kris C. Tierney;
Finance Director Cheryl B. Shiffler; Budget Analyst Jennifer L. Place; Administrative Assistant
Cathy L. Tanner; and members of the Committee.
The Board was presented with an FY 2004 budget. Department heads were given a
determined allocation, met the challenge, and to date the General Fund stands at present level.
Giving the department heads allocated amounts drastically reduced the budget process.
Two budgets were presented to the Board. The present level budget, with the determined
allocation by the county administrator, resulted in the departments absorbing increased costs in other
areas of their budget. The end result (excluding school) equaled the current year amount. The
second budget reflected a zero-tax increase. This exercise was requested by the Board and involved
cuts to the General Fund of$3.2 million below present level funding. The school operating fund was
estimated at $8 million. This budget reduced the level of service provided to the Frederick County
residents and proposed changes included the elimination of core County positions and significantly
reduced coverage in the area of public safety, instituted a pay-as-you-throw program for trash
disposal, recovering fiscal agent costs from other participating localities, and the possible elimination
of 185 positions in the Frederick County schools.
Administrator Riley requested the Board's direction on where to go from here. Staffwanted
the ability to shift funds within the present level general fund budget to areas where funding will
alleviate unusual tight budget constraints. It was also a desire of staff to maintain the current
workforce with competitive salaries and benefits. A directive was also needed to the School Board
for funding the Millbrook High School, increased debt service, and school operational costs. Just
these items alone with the School Board will require an estimated tax increase of approximately 15
Minute Book Number 28
Board of Supervisors Budget Worksession of 01108/03
389
cents. The budget becomes a challenge when real estate taxes are used as the major funding
component of a budget. The 61 cent real estate tax rate in Frederick County is extremely
competitive and much admired by other localities that are considerably higher than the County.
Supervisor Sager referred to the revenue growth for Frederick County. Administrator Riley
estimated a six percent growth in revenue but staff does not feel this amount will cover everything
taken out of reserves last year. The present level budget reflects replacing funds used last year. The
estimated unreserved balance for this budget at this time is $12.8 million, however, this is without
the schools budget submission. These monies are important especially if a crises should ever come
to Frederick County.
Supervisor Smith inquired about the COLA. Finance Director Shiffler advised the Board that
no COLA had been budgeted in the proposed budget. To include the COLA, an estimated $90,000
for each percent would be needed.
Supervisor Sager referred to the automobile decals. Finance Director Shiffler advised the
Board that in July it would generate about $300,000 to $350,000.
Supervisor Reyes asked what type of tax increase the County was looking at with all the
information submitted to date. Administrator Riley advised the Board that with the opening of the
new high school and the increased debt service, this would require a 15 cent increase alone. In
addition, the $2 million dollars taken from fund balance will need to be replaced. The Board will
also need to address Dr. Dean's concern to meet the level of services on the educational side. The
range could be anywhere from 15 to 29 cents. A meeting will need to be held with the School Board
to discuss their budget as staff was not prepared at this time to address these issues.
Supervisor Sager addressed the fire and rescue and law enforcement budgets and if their
budgets were prepared at present level. Administrator Riley advised the Board that their budgets
were prepared at present level which required cuts and is not a realistic budget. A fire and rescue
overtime funding issue will need to be addressed and will be presented to the Board for action later
at the January 8, 2003, regular meeting.
Supervisor Forrester inquired about the Capital Improvements Plan. Administrator Riley
advised that the CIP is adopted with the budget but can be approved later. It is an important plan
in that it is used as a guideline for applicants to proffer to.
Supervisor Sager inquired about the next reassessment. Administrator Riley advised the
Minute Book Number 28
Board of Supervisors Budget Worksession of 01108/03
390
Board they will be making their appointments to the Board of Assessors this spring. The rate will
be set in January of2005. Request for Proposals will be advertised to hire the consultant to do the
reassessment.
Supervisor Tyler addressed the elderly tax relief program, how it works, and ifit needed to
be addressed and what mechanism will need to be used to change it if needed. Commissioner of the
Revenue Ellen Murphy explained that the current scale is, in her opinion, unfair and needed to be
changed. This will require a code amendment in addition to research to make sure this is something
the County could afford to do. Administrator Riley asked Commissioner Murphy to check with the
County attorney to draft a code amendment and to present it to the Code and Ordinance Committee.
Supervisor Forrester addressed the reserve fund. With the economy being the worst that it .
has been in 40 years, she asked ifthe reserve fund balance could be reduced to help fund the budget.
Administrator Riley explained that this could effect the flexibility, when the locality is a fiscal agent,
to advance funds while waiting for reimbursement from the state, reimbursement on sales tax, school
projects and most of all trying to put together a fiscal plan the following year. Supervisor Forrester
referred to Loudoun County's budget and the amounts they keep in reserve fund. Director Shiffler
was directed to obtain information from this locality to understand how their reserve funds are
established.
By unanimous consensus, the Board directed Administrator Riley to go ahead with preparing
a present level budget (no tax increase rate was set).
Frederick County Superintendent of Schools Dr. William C. Dean was asked to contact the
School Board members to schedule a budget worksession with the Board sometime during the week
ofJanuary 23.
Discussions followed concerning a major issue on the Finance Committee Report regarding
Fire and Rescue. A need for six full time firefighters was being requested as an option to alleviate
the overtime expenses within this department. The finance stafftook the average overtime rate and
calculated it to determine what the equivalent full time positions would be needed to offset this
expenditure. Overtime will still be needed but this action would help manage it better. With
continued growth, the demands have become very extensive. Questions were asked where these
firefighters would be placed. Administrator Riley suggested that the Fire and Rescue Association
and the director of fire and rescue determine the placement of these firefighters. If approved by the
Minute Book Number 28
Board of Supervisors Budget Worksession of 01108/03
391
Board, it would be presented at the next Fire and Rescue Association meeting to be held on January
20. An overtime committee has been working with Supervisor Reyes and Fire and Rescue Director
DuBrueler in resolving this issue by using the volunteer force. A first fee for service presentation
is being scheduled for the end ofthis month at the hospital. Several options are being pursued but
until then, the County needs to make sure the calls are met.
Upon motion made by Robert M. Sager, seconded by W. Harrington Smith, Jr., the Board
recessed at this time to go into regular session and was approved by the following recorded vote:
Richard C. Shickle - Aye
W. Harrington Smith, Jr. - Aye
Robert M. Sager - Aye
Margaret B. Douglas - Aye
Sidney A. Reyes - Aye
Lynda J. Tyler - Aye
Gina A. Forrester - Aye
"
. Tanner
istrative Assistant
,
Q.S_J< c~.C --LJ<-~
Richard C. Shickle
Chairman, Board of Supervisors
Minutes Prepared By:
Minute Book Number 28
Board of Supervisors Budget Worksession of 01/08/03